FOLLOW ON PINTEREST WITH OVER 18,700 FOLLOWERS Diane Roark / Recipes for our Daily Bread

There is no custom code to display.

HOW TO MAKE THE BEST OATMEAL TOFFEE COOKIES

HOW TO MAKE THE BEST OATMEAL TOFFEE COOKIES

This post may include affiliate links.  Please see my disclosure.

Prev1 of 2
Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse

These Chunky Chewy Oatmeal Toffee Cookies are from New York Times Bestselling Author Susan Mallery.  Her cookies are the Best Oatmeal Toffee Cookies I have ever had.

#Best Oatmeal Toffee Cookies - These cookies are Chunky Chewy Oatmeal Toffee Cookies are from New York Times Bestselling Author Susan Mallery #Oatmeal #Toffee #cookies #oatmeal cookies

#Best Oatmeal Toffee Cookies - These cookies are Chunky Chewy Oatmeal Toffee Cookies are from New York Times Bestselling Author Susan Mallery #Oatmeal #Toffee #cookies #oatmeal cookies

RECIPE NEXT PAGE

Prev1 of 2
Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse

Visit My Travel Blog, Our American Travels, for Family Fun Travel Ideas All Over America. 

37 Responses to HOW TO MAKE THE BEST OATMEAL TOFFEE COOKIES

    • Angela,

      I am grew up in Mobile, Alabama. After I got married, we lived in Montgomery for about 9 years. Alabama will always be my home. I have lots of family that lives there.
      We really enjoy these Oatmeal cookies. I have made several batches of these cookies lately and put some of them in the freezer. They freeze well. I scoop them out with an ice cream scoop first.

      You are entered into the drawing for Susan’s cookbook. I will e-mail a winner on 11/19/13. Check this post for the winner to be announced.

      I added a post today with a huge list of my favorite cookies & candy recipes for the holidays.
      You may also like to view my Gooseberry Patch Cookbook giveaway. http://recipesforourdailybread.com/2013/11/25/holiday-brown-sugar-ham-gooseberry-cookbook-giveaway/
      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.
      I am planning for next year 2014 and would love to hear what kind of recipes you would like for me to post about. Crock-Pot recipes? Healthier recipes? Kid Friendly recipes? Easy Recipes? Pressure Cooker recipes? Casseroles? Skillet Dishes? Sandwiches? Or do you have another idea? Please leave me a comment and let me know.

      Blessings and WONDERFUL CHRISTMAS SEASON!!
      Diane Roark

  1. I love oatmeal cookies and will definitely be trying these. All the recipes sound good; am hoping to win this cookbook.

    • Karen,

      We really enjoy these Oatmeal cookies. I have made several batches of these cookies lately and put some of them in the freezer. They freeze well. I scoop them out with an ice cream scoop first.

      You are entered into the drawing for Susan’s cookbook. I will e-mail a winner on 11/19/13. Check this post for the winner to be announced.

      I added a post today with a huge list of my favorite cookies & candy recipes for the holidays.
      You may also like to view my Gooseberry Patch Cookbook giveaway. http://recipesforourdailybread.com/2013/11/25/holiday-brown-sugar-ham-gooseberry-cookbook-giveaway/
      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.

      Blessings and have a great week!
      Diane Roark

    • Martha,

      YOU MADE MY DAY! Where are you from? Please tell your family I am so thankful they tried these cookies. I am also so thankful you found my blog.
      I have made several batches of these cookies lately and put some of them in the freezer. They freeze well. I scoop them out with an ice cream scoop first.

      You are entered into the drawing for Susan’s cookbook. I will e-mail a winner on 11/19/13. Check this post for the winner to be announced.

      I am adding a post this Saturday with a huge list of my favorite cookies & candy recipes for the holidays.
      You may also like to view my Gooseberry Patch Cookbook giveaway. http://recipesforourdailybread.com/2013/11/25/holiday-brown-sugar-ham-gooseberry-cookbook-giveaway/
      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.

      Blessings and have a great week!
      Diane Roark

    • Pat,

      I love the chunky chewy combination of oats, toffee, and pecans.
      You are entered into the drawing for Susan’s cookbook. I will e-mail a winner on 11/19/13. Check this post for the winner to be announced.

      I am adding a post this Saturday with a huge list of my favorite cookies & candy recipes for the holidays.
      You may also like to view my Gooseberry Patch Cookbook giveaway. http://recipesforourdailybread.com/2013/11/25/holiday-brown-sugar-ham-gooseberry-cookbook-giveaway/
      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.

      Blessings and have a great week!
      Diane Roark

    • Amy,

      I hope you have a wonderful Christmas season. Thank you so much for taking the time to stop by and leave me a comment. I truly loved Susan Mallery’s Cookbook. It is full of great recipes and wonderful pictures. These Oatmeal Toffee cookies are really delicious. I have made several batches lately.

      You are entered into the drawing for Susan’s cookbook. I will e-mail a winner on 11/19/13. Check this post for the winner to be announced.

      I am adding a post this Saturday with a huge list of my favorite cookies & candy recipes for the holidays.
      You may also like to view my Gooseberry Patch Cookbook giveaway. http://recipesforourdailybread.com/2013/11/25/holiday-brown-sugar-ham-gooseberry-cookbook-giveaway/
      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.

      Blessings and have a great week!
      Diane Roark

    • Robyn,

      We really love these cookies. I will probably make a 4th batch soon. I truly enjoyed Susan’s cookbook. I read all of her recipes and plan on making several more.

      You are entered into the drawing for Susan’s cookbook. I will e-mail a winner on 11/19/13. Check this post for the winner to be announced.

      I am adding a post this Saturday with a huge list of my favorite cookies & candy recipes for the holidays.
      You may also like to view my Gooseberry Patch Cookbook giveaway. http://recipesforourdailybread.com/2013/11/25/holiday-brown-sugar-ham-gooseberry-cookbook-giveaway/
      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.

      Blessings and have a great week!
      Diane Roark

  2. These cookies look and sound so good! I’m glad I found this website, I can add this to come to. I would love to win Susan’s Cookbook! Thanks for such an awesome giveaway!

    • Donna,

      These cookies are as good as they look and sound. I love the chunky chewy combination of oats, toffee, and pecans.
      You are entered into the drawing for Susan’s cookbook. I will e-mail a winner on 11/19/13. Check this post for the winner to be announced.

      I am adding a post this Saturday with a huge list of my favorite cookies & candy recipes for the holidays.
      You may also like to view my Gooseberry Patch Cookbook giveaway. http://recipesforourdailybread.com/2013/11/25/holiday-brown-sugar-ham-gooseberry-cookbook-giveaway/
      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.

      Blessings and have a great week!
      Diane Roark

    • Bridget,

      I love the chunky chewy combination of oats, toffee, and pecans.
      You are entered into the drawing for Susan’s cookbook. I will e-mail a winner on 11/19/13. Check this post for the winner to be announced.

      I am adding a post this Saturday with a huge list of my favorite cookies & candy recipes for the holidays.
      You may also like to view my Gooseberry Patch Cookbook giveaway. http://recipesforourdailybread.com/2013/11/25/holiday-brown-sugar-ham-gooseberry-cookbook-giveaway/
      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.

      Blessings and have a great week!
      Diane Roark
      Stay Warm! We are preparing for a major ice storm in Arkansas this weekend.

    • Renee,

      Thank you so much for stopping by and leaving me a comment. I truly enjoyed Susan Mallery’s cookbook. I plan on making many other of her recipes.

      You are entered into the drawing for Susan’s cookbook. I will e-mail a winner on 11/19/13. Check this post for the winner to be announced.

      I am adding a post this Saturday with a huge list of my favorite cookies & candy recipes for the holidays.
      You may also like to view my Gooseberry Patch Cookbook giveaway. http://recipesforourdailybread.com/2013/11/25/holiday-brown-sugar-ham-gooseberry-cookbook-giveaway/
      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.

      Blessings and have a great week!
      Diane Roark

    • Terri,

      Yes it did get great reviews. I know I truly enjoyed it. I read all of her recipes and plan on making several more.

      You are entered into the drawing for Susan’s cookbook. I will e-mail a winner on 11/19/13. Check this post for the winner to be announced.

      I am adding a post this Saturday with a huge list of my favorite cookies & candy recipes for the holidays.
      You may also like to view my Gooseberry Patch Cookbook giveaway. http://recipesforourdailybread.com/2013/11/25/holiday-brown-sugar-ham-gooseberry-cookbook-giveaway/
      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.

      Blessings and have a great week!
      Diane Roark

  3. So if the cookies are half as good as the Susan’s Cranberry Dip – I’m so in trouble! I’ve now made seven batches of Susan’s Cranberry Dip since Thanksgiving!!!! Thank you!!!

    • Jeannie,

      Susan’s cranberry dip is not in this cookbook. I am going to go right now and google it. It sounds like I missed out. I truly enjoyed Susan’s cookbook. I read all of her recipes and plan on making several more.

      You are entered into the drawing for Susan’s cookbook. I will e-mail a winner on 11/19/13. Check this post for the winner to be announced.

      I am adding a post this Saturday with a huge list of my favorite cookies & candy recipes for the holidays.
      You may also like to view my Gooseberry Patch Cookbook giveaway. http://recipesforourdailybread.com/2013/11/25/holiday-brown-sugar-ham-gooseberry-cookbook-giveaway/
      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.

      Blessings and have a great week!
      Diane Roark

  4. Diane, This recipe looks yummy. I’m headed to the store to get more oats. I Can’ t wait to see what else is in the cookbook.

  5. Thank you for this chance and for the yummy recipe.
    I will mention that your blog has the end date as 11/18 which is confusing.

    • Laura,

      You are so welcome!! I truly appreciate you stopping by. I will double check the date. It is 12/18/13. I truly loved these cookies. They were full of oats, toffee, and pecans which are great together.

      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.

      Blessings and have a great week!
      Diane Roark

  6. Mmm. Not only do I love baking but I absolutely love trying different recipes. Cookie party time is coming up and bringing different things so everyone can try something new is just as exciting as making them.

  7. I love Susan Mallery’s Fools Gold books. When I found out that she came out with a Fool’s Gold cookbook, I was really excited. Not because it’s related to Fool’s Gold but because it’s a cookbook filled with new recipes for me to try out with my friends. The cookie recipe posted here looks and sounds really good! I’m gonna try it with my friends sometime.

  8. These look sooo good, I cant wait to try the recipe! Thank you for your daily blog and for all the yummy recipes you share with us…God bless you and have a beautiful day!

    • Theresa,

      Thank you so much for stopping by this morning. I truly loved these cookies. I hope you enjoy them too. Please let me know what you think if you make them.

      I am a Southern Food & Travel blogger & a Christian. I blog about RECIPES, RESTAURANT REVIEWS, FAITH, FAMILY, TRAVEL EXPERIENCES & GIVEAWAYS.

      I would love for you to follow my blog by entering your e-mail on the top right hand corner of my homepage.

      Blessings and have a great week!
      Diane Roark

  9. Ok, my favorite cookie of all time is oatmeal and I love Heathbar toffee. Seriously, I use it as a topping on my ice cream very often. So, I am so making these for me and whoever wants to eat bonus. But when I go grocery shopping this weekend and making sure to buy extra Heathbar toffee bits and more oats to make these cookies. Thank you for sharing and also for the giveaway here today, too. Happy Wednesday!! 🙂

    • Janine,

      I was very impressed with these cookies. My only issue was the recipe did not make enough. I hope you enjoy these cookies.

      Thank you for stopping by. After a record breaking month up until Thanksgiving day, it has been very slow. Are you finding the same thing?

      Blessings and have a great day!
      Diane Roark

Leave a reply

Rate this recipe:  

CommentLuv badge

This blog uses premium CommentLuv which allows you to put your keywords with your name if you have had 0 approved comments. Use your real name and then @ your keywords (maximum of 0)

CONNECT!

Connect with us via email or social media or check out some other great sites that we love!

SEND ME A MESSAGE!

Checking...

Ouch! There was a server error.
Retry »

Sending message...

MENU